Jeffrey Combs...Poe’s Moustache

October 9, 2013 — Last Wednesday evening, I was introducing my wife to Re-Animator. I had no idea that the very next night, I’d be talking to the star of the movie himself, Jeffrey Combs.

I’d heard that Combs and his Re-Animator director Stuart Gordon had launched a Kickstarter for a movie about Edgar Allan Poe, with Combs in the role of Poe. And, as you now, Poe is on my radar these days. Well, Poe is my radar these days.

Something I’ve become fascinated with as a result of the book project is people who have walked in Poe’s worn-through shoes. From professional actors like John Astin to local literary historians, people love to play Poe. I wanted to talk to Combs in particular because he’s performed the poet on TV (in a Showtime Masters of Horror episode called The Black Cat), in a one-man play called Nevermore, and, if the Kickstarter gets funded, in a movie based on that play.

He’s got a Poe trifecta lined up, and if there’s anybody with some unique Poe insight, it’s gotta be him.

I recently became friends with Bryan Moore who did the horror genre a huge service with his recent sculpt of the H.P. Lovecraft bust in Providence. I figured he might have a way to get a message to Combs. Turns out, they knew each other from way back. Bryan did a life-sculpt of Combs for a statuette of his Re-Animator persona Herbert West. Hours after contacting Bryan, I was on the phone with Combs.

And I only tell you that backstory so that you know it wasn’t a press junket. This was just a guy willing to talk Poe with me. I mean, sure, this was also a guy with a project to push, but he took a lot of time out to chat with me despite what little I could offer that project in return.

Calling people is usually hard for me to do, whether it’s my mom or the dentist. Fortunately, calling a genre legend was too surreal to be a problem. Just 10 digits later, I heard a “Hello?” on the other end.

“Mr. Combs?” I asked uncertainly. It was a formality. I recognized his voice right away, and not just because I’d heard it for an hour and a half the previous night. He’s got a recognizable voice, and you can pick him out even when he’s hidden under layers of makeup for his Star Trek roles or doing voice-overs for cartoons like Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated or Justice League Unlimited.

We eased into the conversation by talking a bit about the app we were using to connect. He was filming his latest movie in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and even though I could’ve almost thrown a football to him from where I am in New Hampshire, the phone bill would have been like calling the Mars Rover since it crossed an international line. But Combs, with the knowledge of a man who travels frequently for location shooting, had suggested over email an app we could use to circumvent all that.

But then we quickly got down to black cats. That was supposed to be a pun on brass tacks. I don’t think it worked.

“So tell me how this Poe thing got started for you. I mean, you’ve done him for TV, the stage, and now you’re looking to do him on film. That sounds like more than just a passing interest or just accepting a role.”

“It’s funny,” he said, “I love history, and years and years ago, I was looking around for a historical character I could portray—not as a one-man show—but in whatever. Just something to really broaden my reputation beyond a horror and science fiction actor. I happened to be reading a biography of Poe at the time, although I was completely resistant to him as the character I was looking for, for obvious reasons.

“But after that biography I became fascinated by him…by his psychology, his contrasts, his character, the way he seemed to switch from genteel to raving in the gutter. It also helped that I’m his height, that we have the same eye color, so just physically he was a fit for me.”

“What do you mean, his contrasts?” I asked.

“I remember throwing down the book at one point and thinking, ‘What a pathetic guy. You’re begging people for money all the time, even asking for loans from the people whom you’ve written bad reviews about.’ He could be so beautifully poetic and then so crass.”

“Yeah, I’m about halfway through his letters, and, honestly, he often comes off as unlikeable.”

“Exactly. You don’t like him, and it’s disappointing. But I see him as America’s Van Gogh, a tortured soul and brilliant…I don’t think he was steeped in Van Gogh’s madness, but I think there are parallels, including the fact that neither had two nickels to rub together. Poe did get some notoriety, though, just not what he should have.

“And that’s kind of another connection I made with Poe. He got his notoriety from stories that he kind of looked down on. We think they’re genius, but he thought he was debasing himself to write them. He wanted to be poet. In a small way, it’s like me and Lovecraft. People always come to me and ask if I read a lot of Lovecraft growing up, but I didn’t live off of peanut butter sandwiches and spend six years learning the basics of my craft just so I could do Lovecraft. It found me. I didn’t find it. I guess people like it, and it perpetuated itself.”

“So you did the Masters of Horror episode, and that just turned into the stage show?”

“The one-man show is not actually something I’d ever have thought to do, but with the economic downturn, things really dried up. It was the Sahara out there. So I needed to do stuff that I could control, and after The Black Cat, Stuart really convinced me that it was something we should do.”

That’s Stuart Gordon, who is Tim Burton to Combs’ Johnny Depp. In addition to directing him in Re-Animator and half a dozen other movies, he also directed Combs in the Masters of Horror episode and Nevermore.

“Tell me more about Nevermore.”

“Did you see it?”

“Uh, no.” I wondered if that’s the worst thing you can tell an actor.

“Ok, I just wanted to know how much detail to go into. We deal a lot with those contrasts we were talking about.”

Combs then went on to describe Nevermore’s take on Poe’s story. The play, using minimal props and effects and basically just relying on Combs, shows Poe transmographying from the Southern gentleman that Poe loved being to—as he gets drunker—a bolder, embittered, erratic man. It then ends with a sad redemption of sorts that sobers him up…the departure of Sarah Helen Whitman, the woman he was betrothed to after the death of his wife. Interspersed throughout the performance, Combs also performs a selection of Poe’s works.

“About 90% of what I say comes directly from Poe, but we, of course, deviate from historical accounts to push the narrative to the salient points. Early in the night I read The Tell-Tale Heart, pulling out the bottle while I’m doing it, and that’s when the audience really reacts. That’s when the party starts.

“I had an alcoholic uncle as a kid, a weekend alcoholic. Throughout the week he was uncolorful, mumbled a lot, but on the weekend, he was a bigger, more theatrical version of himself, free, entertaining…so I wanted to go on that kind of journey with Poe. “

“So you performed Nevermore for three years in cities across the continent. What’s it like to be Poe for so long?”

“I’m not the type of actor who has to be the character all the time, but it’s Poe. There’s a melancholia that you’re steeped in with him and it gets to you. My wife actually told me at one point, “God, why don’t you stop doing this play.”

I made a note: Jeffrey Combs’ wife calls him God.

“But you know what was really intense about the show for me, was the one-man aspect of it on top of a relatively bleak character. I didn’t realize what a lonely journey it is to have a one-man show. Nobody to commiserate with. Nobody to get drinks with afterward to blow off steam. Nobody to get into the moment with.

At this point, I assume Combs looked down at his phone, because he interjected, “Are you in Frederick, Maryland?” He pronounced the location like it was foreign country.

“Ha. No, I’m in New England. I lived in Frederick for a few years and that’s why I have that area code. I still have family there, actually.” Frederick’s about half an hour above Washington, D.C. With traffic, about four.

“I just shot a movie there not a year and a half ago or so.

“What? They do that in Frederick? What’s the movie?

“It’s called Elf-Man.”

I IMDB’d the movie right there, thinking it was a horror project. Turns out, it’s a Christmas movie with Wee-Man from Jackass. I moved it into my mental Netflix queue for when the seasons rolls around.

“So obviously you’re not done with Poe, even after all these years. Why the movie, and how do you translate a one-man show like yours to the screen?”

“Ever since I got into Poe, I’ve wondered why don’t we have the great American movie about the great American writer. I kind of think of him as the human condition writ large…our highs and lows exaggerated in Poe.

“I’m not the definitive answer to Poe, but I’d love to give him a good shot. I have this experience with him and I love the poor guy, such an underdog.

"As for the movie, this will give us a chance to actually depict his stories and poems throughout this overarching story of Poe himself.”

“And you’re turning to Kickstarter to try to make it happen?”

“Yeah. I’m a little bit out of my depth with Kickstarter. I have trouble pushing myself onto people, ‘Hey support me. I’m good.’ It’s out of my comfort zone. We got a good response to the Kickstarter at first, but we’re to the point that the goal is the Andes and we only have one lama.”

“So let me ask you this. If the Kickstarter doesn’t fund, and if you can’t get funding from elsewhere…”

Here he interrupted, “Which is probable. If the Kickstarter doesn’t fund, people will use that as evidence for no public interest, no matter how much money gets pledged.”

“So if it doesn’t get funded, then do you still continue to do Poe or are you done with him?

“If it doesn’t happen,” here his tone became a little reluctant, but gradually firmed, “yeah, I’ll hang up the costume and look for other challenges. An actor friend of mine once told me, ‘All shows close.’ ”

And so do interviews. But the takeaway here is clear. If we want to see Combs and Gordon and, I should mention, Dennis Paoli, who was the writer for Nevermore and many other Combs/Gordon projects, really show us their version of Poe, we need to fund the Kickstarter. I for one, would love to see it, especially since I missed the play version.

I mean, as close to Poe has I’ve gotten over the past year…as close as holding his handwritten poems in my hand, as close as kneeling by his wife’s deathbed, as close as, well, six feet above his bones, I’ll never know what it’s like to don the ‘stache and really feel his work from inside.

So I rely on people like Combs to do that for me.

So one last time, here’s the link to the Kickstarter.


  1. I will watch Jeffrey Combs in anything he is in, great actor! How lucky you are to have been able to talk to him one on one.

  2. I saw the Nevermore show in Baltimore a few years ago. While I really liked the show, it does pain me to see yet another take on Poe that completely exaggerates his drinking. Poe was not an alcoholic in the modern sense of the word. Poe was not dependent upon alcohol. More than one of Poe's friends commented on how Poe could not drink, that if he had just one drink, he'd be under the table. And this seems to be Poe's problem with drinking: several times in his life he did have that drink (and NOT drinking alcohol in the 19th Century was a hard thing to do) and got completely wasted, so it seemed as if he had a problem. Add that to the notorious bio that Rufus Griswold wrote (and we know that Griswold was making shit up about Poe), and the myth about Poe being a drunkard begins.
    Of all the myths to dispel about Poe (drinking, drugs, murder, madness), this one seems to be the hardest. People seem to want Poe to be a drunk.